Can't find the thread where there was chat about Hayes :

 

Aberdeen face a three-way fight with Hibernian and St Johnstone to land Inverness winger Jonny Hayes. (Sun)

Would take him in a heartbeat. Frees up Considine to play center with Anderson which could be a solid partnership if they stay fit. Also as said, someone experienced to help Robertson as well

Full-back. Sign it.

He is on trial, apparently going to Germany

Naysmith would be an excellent addition.

Agreed with the above sentiments. We shouldn't turn him down, providing he's injury free

Agreed with the above sentiments. We shouldn't turn him down, providing he's injury free

 

didn't seem to matter when we signed Anderson!

Gary Naysmith is allegedly just training with us.

However at 33 provided he still has a good level of fitness, I actually reckon he could still do a job for us in this season's SPL

Absolutely cracking player in his prime, I'd take him in a heartbeat if he's fit, could be a great example to our younger players. The SPL would hold no fears for him.

Would take him in a heartbeat. Frees up Considine to play center with Anderson which IS a solid partnership if they stay fit. Also as said, someone experienced to help Robertson as well

 

Edited for accuracy.

Good:

 

Agent Football @AgentScotland

Aberdeen have been encouraged to sign Gary Naysmith after learning he's willing to deal for £1500 per week

 

Bad:

 

Agent Football @AgentScotland

Gary Kenneth has attracted interest from both Aberdeen and Hibs, he wants to go to England but offers are scarce so SPL now showing interest

The Gary Kenneth thing is shite. 

The Gary Kenneth thing is shite. 

 

Kenneth looked a player when he had webster along side him controlling the line imo

Gary Naysmith is 33 I thought he was about 43! It's felt like he has been about for a lot longer than that. I quite like Gary Kenneth actually. A bit of a liability at times but most of out CBs have been. Surely another full back would be better 

Jesus Christ, we'll end up with the most immobile defence in the history of the SPL.

Jesus Christ, we'll end up with the most immobile defence in the history of the SPL.

 

Kenneth is a poorer version of Diamond. 

I'd take an immobile defence over no defence.

Still gonna be better than Inglis?

There's been worse than Inglis.

 

Chic McClelland.............

There's been worse

 

That is a depressingly acurate statement.

Never saw him (or heard of him for that matter) but the worst cb i.have seen in red was solberg

There's been worse than Inglis.

 

Chic McClelland.............

 

Chick McLelland was not worse than Inglis, and he was a LB as I remember?

Indeed he was. ( a LB, the other debate is always going to be slanted by personal opinions)

I thought we were talking about poor defenders generally, not just poor central defenders.

If its generally bad defenders McQuilken must be tops!!  :o  Now playing at Cambuslang Rangers!! At least he has found his level.

I don't think McLelland was that bad. Used to be in a Kennedy, Miller, Garner McLelland defence which, if memory serves, was pretty tight.

 

He was certainly better than Steve Ritchie!