Jump to content

Saturday 20th September 2025, kick-off 3pm

🏆 Scottish League Cup 🏆 

Aberdeen v Motherwell

Just signed up to DonsTalk? Check your SPAM mailbox for your DonsTalk validation email - Click for more info

Steven Gunn

wee toon red

By wee toon red
in Aberdeen Football Club

Recommended Posts

BigAl

BigAl

Posted
Posted

As an aside, I have zero recollection of us having a player called David Lawrie being with us during the 80's but from what I can see online he was a goalkeeper but left to pursue a career out with football and went to Robert Gordon's.

Anyone else mind anything about him ?

wokinginashearerwonderland

wokinginashearerwonderland

Posted
Posted

Hard position to recruit for I'd imagine.  In an ideal world I think it would be great to have an older type who knows the club, maybe an ex-manager who had been around the block a bit but hard to think of anyone like that.  Most of our ex-managers have not been very good. Hope it is someone who has seen it and done it rather than some young whipper snapper who is just out of college and talks about underlapping full backs, low blocks and transitions. 

Knowing Dave, he will appoint someone like Carlos Bocanegra.  You heard it here first. 😉

RicoS321

RicoS321

Posted
Posted
50 minutes ago, wokinginashearerwonderland said:

Hard position to recruit for I'd imagine.  In an ideal world I think it would be great to have an older type who knows the club, maybe an ex-manager who had been around the block a bit but hard to think of anyone like that.  Most of our ex-managers have not been very good. Hope it is someone who has seen it and done it rather than some young whipper snapper who is just out of college and talks about underlapping full backs, low blocks and transitions. 

Knowing Dave, he will appoint someone like Carlos Bocanegra.  You heard it here first. 😉

I don't think it's essential that it's a former manager either. It needs someone that holds the manager to account, plays devil's advocate and makes sure that the tactics, signings, youth minutes etc align with the strategy. 

Jute

Jute

Posted
Posted

Only draw back with appointing a sporting director now is we already have a manager in place. Usually (in Europe) it’s the sporting director who is responsible for setting the long term approach/style of  the club will take then selecting the coaching team to execute that plan. We already have a manager in place so you are probably looking with getting in a sporting director who agrees with his approach so maybe reduces the checks and balances effect. 

RicoS321

RicoS321

Posted
Posted
13 minutes ago, Jute said:

Only draw back with appointing a sporting director now is we already have a manager in place. Usually (in Europe) it’s the sporting director who is responsible for setting the long term approach/style of  the club will take then selecting the coaching team to execute that plan. We already have a manager in place so you are probably looking with getting in a sporting director who agrees with his approach so maybe reduces the checks and balances effect. 

If only some of us had thought have that years ago.

Although I suspect it's not unusual for a sporting director to leave post while a manager is in place, so we can just treat it like that.

wokinginashearerwonderland

wokinginashearerwonderland

Posted
Posted
2 hours ago, Jute said:

Only draw back with appointing a sporting director now is we already have a manager in place. Usually (in Europe) it’s the sporting director who is responsible for setting the long term approach/style of  the club will take then selecting the coaching team to execute that plan. We already have a manager in place so you are probably looking with getting in a sporting director who agrees with his approach so maybe reduces the checks and balances effect. 

Presumably we are not looking at reinventing the wheel though? We already have a director of football so this new person surely would be continuing with the existing plan…..or are we just tearing it all up on the Monday morning and starting again? If that is the case we might as well just fire the manager and stick the whole squad up for sale.

OrlandoDon

OrlandoDon

Posted
Posted
6 minutes ago, wokinginashearerwonderland said:

Presumably we are not looking at reinventing the wheel though? We already have a director of football so this new person surely would be continuing with the existing plan…..or are we just tearing it all up on the Monday morning and starting again? If that is the case we might as well just fire the manager and stick the whole squad up for sale.

I’d assume it’s Dave and the board who determine the direction of the club and the roles of key personnel. While the title and responsibilities of the role may be different, I’d assume the philosophy behind the role and the key responsibilities don’t overly change. I don’t see us significantly changing our transfer strategy for example, but this person may provide our management team with a different kind of support. the hire is no doubt culturally aligned with Dave and the board so should be aligned with Thelin. I think….? I’d also assume Thelin will have input to this role and be involved in the hiring process.

  • Like 2
Jute

Jute

Posted
Posted
3 hours ago, wokinginashearerwonderland said:

Presumably we are not looking at reinventing the wheel though? We already have a director of football so this new person surely would be continuing with the existing plan…..or are we just tearing it all up on the Monday morning and starting again? If that is the case we might as well just fire the manager and stick the whole squad up for sale.

From what I have read and heard Gunn’s role was more an administrative role than a football role so if we are going down the European style sporting director role that was recommend in the review carried out I think it would be a different role to the one Gunn had.
 

I suspect you and Orlando are right in saying that with manager already in place we won’t be looking at changing the approach so as I said it is likely that anyone brought in will be someone who is willing to work within the current approach to recruitment and playing style. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...