2stars Posted 7 hours ago Report Posted 7 hours ago The Clarkson one I find most disappointing- never fully recreated the impact he had in the loan spell- very talented player and can argue whether we didn’t properly utilise him or his standards dropped, just wasn’t consistent enough, but sorry it didn’t work out in the end feel with the right manager he could have been a cracking player for us and sure the club saw him as an investment that would bring in large sum after a couple of years  4 Quote
The.Moog Posted 7 hours ago Report Posted 7 hours ago 11 minutes ago, Panda said: A "significant fee" paid apparently Can’t say I’m too fussed. Clearly talented but affa lightweight physically and I’d say mentally too. Maybe wasn’t always used the way which suited him best tbf, but he’s not got a regular game in this utterly honking team, so that says a lot. All the best though min, but probs best all round this one… 1 Quote
2stars Posted 7 hours ago Report Posted 7 hours ago 6 minutes ago, Kowalski said: We are a fucking shambles of a club. Gutted Clarkson’s gone and wish him all the best.  Lutz out! Not sure Lutz can be blamed for this one- wanted away in summer and when it didn’t happen he was frozen out- long before Lutz arrived with no idea who is coming in, guess Clarkson just wants a fresh challenge where he is likely to play every week can’t blame the lad and wish him all the best  2 Quote
tlg1903 Posted 7 hours ago Report Posted 7 hours ago 4 minutes ago, 2stars said: The Clarkson one I find most disappointing- never fully recreated the impact he had in the loan spell- very talented player and can argue whether we didn’t properly utilise him or his standards dropped, just wasn’t consistent enough, but sorry it didn’t work out in the end feel with the right manager he could have been a cracking player for us and sure the club saw him as an investment that would bring in large sum after a couple of years  nailed it Quote
tlg1903 Posted 7 hours ago Report Posted 7 hours ago So we now have Shinnie, Nilsen, Armstrong, Aremu, Geiger, Cameron and Palaversa for the central midfield positions. Suspect the club will be trying to move Palaversa also Quote
2stars Posted 7 hours ago Report Posted 7 hours ago 3 minutes ago, tlg1903 said: So we now have Shinnie, Nilsen, Armstrong, Aremu, Geiger, Cameron and Palaversa for the central midfield positions. Suspect the club will be trying to move Palaversa also Rumours that he may be going to a league where window is open longer- Croatia? Quote
Kowalski Posted 7 hours ago Report Posted 7 hours ago 8 minutes ago, 2stars said: Not sure Lutz can be blamed for this one- wanted away in summer and when it didn’t happen he was frozen out- long before Lutz arrived with no idea who is coming in, guess Clarkson just wants a fresh challenge where he is likely to play every week can’t blame the lad and wish him all the best  Happy with the results, style of play and recruitment since Lutz arrived? Looks like we’re going down the hoof ball route by getting rid of anyone close to being a baller. With a decent holding midfielder (such as Geiger hopefully) and we could have built the team round Clarkson. Quote
tlg1903 Posted 7 hours ago Report Posted 7 hours ago Just now, 2stars said: Rumours that he may be going to a league where window is open longer- Croatia? would seem a good choice for him Quote
Kowalski Posted 7 hours ago Report Posted 7 hours ago 9 minutes ago, tlg1903 said: So we now have Shinnie, Nilsen, Armstrong, Aremu, Geiger, Cameron and Palaversa for the central midfield positions. Suspect the club will be trying to move Palaversa also So three mid 30s, two loans until end of season, plus one we’ve not seen for months and likely to exit, which leaves one actual long term signing in Aremu. Quote
tlg1903 Posted 7 hours ago Report Posted 7 hours ago 1 minute ago, Kowalski said: Happy with the results, style of play and recruitment since Lutz arrived? Looks like we’re going down the hoof ball route by getting rid of anyone close to being a baller. With a decent holding midfielder (such as Geiger hopefully) and we could have built the team round Clarkson. Geiger doesn't look like a holding midfielder from the little I've seen. Far more a B2B, in your face cm but time will tell on that. He also hasn't played for 6 months so I'm not exactly xpecting miracles from him straight away. A lot will depend on how fit he has kept himself but he didn't look to be carryin pork in his RTV interview. 1 Quote
2stars Posted 7 hours ago Report Posted 7 hours ago 2 minutes ago, Kowalski said: Happy with the results, style of play and recruitment since Lutz arrived? Looks like we’re going down the hoof ball route by getting rid of anyone close to being a baller. With a decent holding midfielder (such as Geiger hopefully) and we could have built the team round Clarkson. Not at all- and he might be as big a charlatan, if not the biggest one as the others in our set up- just don’t think this one is on him Jury very much out for me on Lutz 1 Quote
tlg1903 Posted 7 hours ago Report Posted 7 hours ago 1 minute ago, Kowalski said: So three mid 30s, two loans until end of season, plus one we’ve not seen for months and likely to exit, which leaves one actual long term signing in Aremu. yeah that's about the size of it. what could go worng? Quote
BigAl Posted 7 hours ago Author Report Posted 7 hours ago Just home from being out on the piss in Glasgow Catching up on matters Kind of feel I have missed sweet fuck all Looks like time to move on to Summer '26 window,assuming we haven't gone out of business before that Quote
2stars Posted 7 hours ago Report Posted 7 hours ago 6 minutes ago, Kowalski said: Happy with the results, style of play and recruitment since Lutz arrived? on the recruitment, as others mentioned earlier, moving the choices from manager to DoF without checks being done is asking for trouble genuinely hope the 2 midfielders that have worked with Lutz before are decent and upgrade but apart from them not playing regularly, when was the last time he actually watched them play ? no difference to Thelin taking in Karllson Nilsen Jensen 2 Quote
Panda Posted 7 hours ago Report Posted 7 hours ago 14 minutes ago, Kowalski said: Happy with the results, style of play and recruitment since Lutz arrived? Holding Lutz responsible for everything is a weird flex. Considering he's been busy with recruitment and interviews, I don't think he's spent a great deal of time on the training ground or picking the team. 14 minutes ago, Kowalski said:   11 minutes ago, Kowalski said: So three mid 30s, two loans until end of season, plus one we’ve not seen for months and likely to exit, which leaves one actual long term signing in Aremu. There is an option to buy Geiger. And if we're talking long term, there is also Kjartansson, Marshall and a summer transfer window. Quote
BigAl Posted 7 hours ago Author Report Posted 7 hours ago Take it Watson hasn't signed the pre contract yet Quote
tlg1903 Posted 7 hours ago Report Posted 7 hours ago Just now, 2stars said: on the recruitment, as others mentioned earlier, moving the choices from manager to DoF without checks being done is asking for trouble genuinely hope the 2 midfielders that have worked with Lutz before are decent and upgrade but apart from them not playing regularly, when was the last time he actually watched them play ? no difference to Thelin taking in Karllson Nilsen Jensen Lutz worked a lot on tv doing co-comms with Derek Rae so will likely have seen some of them 2bf. On the face of it Geiger is a player who should be out of our range, even on loan let alone with an option, if you ask me though. 1 Quote
tlg1903 Posted 7 hours ago Report Posted 7 hours ago 1 minute ago, BigAl said: Take it Watson hasn't signed the pre contract yet Not yet Quote
Kowalski Posted 7 hours ago Report Posted 7 hours ago 4 minutes ago, Panda said: Holding Lutz responsible for everything is a weird flex. Considering he's been busy with recruitment and interviews, I don't think he's spent a great deal of time on the training ground or picking the team  Not to mention sitting on the bench during matches as well. 1 Quote
BigAl Posted 7 hours ago Author Report Posted 7 hours ago 2 minutes ago, tlg1903 said: Not yet Maybe I should nip up the road to Killie and convince him to get it done  1 Quote
manc_don Posted 7 hours ago Report Posted 7 hours ago 47 minutes ago, Kowalski said: We are a fucking shambles of a club. Gutted Clarkson’s gone and wish him all the best.  Lutz out! Really should have built a team around him. But we've fucked everything up over the last season and a bit. 2 Quote
Jute Posted 7 hours ago Report Posted 7 hours ago 17 minutes ago, Panda said: Holding Lutz responsible for everything is a weird flex. Considering he's been busy with recruitment and interviews, I don't think he's spent a great deal of time on the training ground or picking the team.  There is an option to buy Geiger. And if we're talking long term, there is also Kjartansson, Marshall and a summer transfer window. Marshall’s contract expires in June and he is now free to talk to other teams. I suspect we will not see him in an Aberdeen shirt now. 2 Quote
BigAl Posted 6 hours ago Author Report Posted 6 hours ago 3 minutes ago, Jute said: Marshall’s contract expires in June and he is now free to talk to other teams. I suspect we will not see him in an Aberdeen shirt now. Not saying he would be good enough but would have liked to have seen him given a chance at some point 2 Quote
RicoS321 Posted 6 hours ago Report Posted 6 hours ago Sad to see Clarkson go, a complete failure by the club in that regard. I'm guessing that the writing has been on the wall with him for weeks though, and the signing of Cameron probably confirmed it. From that perspective, I'm a little glad he's gone, because another 6 months of his obvious talent sitting on our bench while we train up a Hun would have been unbearable! Cameron probably the only one there who could fulfil the deep lying role that Clarkson performed now though. It's so often the car that you eventually (potentially) get the players in the door to compliment a player just as he's leaving, and the two new midfielders look to do just that. Oh well. 2 Quote
BigAl Posted 6 hours ago Author Report Posted 6 hours ago Window closed Shitey freebies still available Summer 2026 window thread next up. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.