How would you mark CB's report card after 39 games in charge

[mizer]

Thoughts?

[Jute]

3 wins in last 20 matches, not signing full backs, signing Chris Clark, and lack of creation in the team all point towards failing for me.

[manc_don]

Insufficient. Once again we have an incredibly unbalanced team, how can it be so difficult to see?!?

[rocket_scientist]

Not good enough, irrespective of the fact he has shit bosses in Milne and Miller.

 

Archie Knox and Paw Broon. It ain't working and strong evidence suggests it ain't gonna work under you very old men of yesterdecade.

[Sharpie]

We are overloaded with central midfielders and mediocre forwards. Totally mispent budget.

[Superstar Tradesman]

I'm not going to comment on his performance other than to say that he seems to have made the exact same errors as McGhee in overloading areas of the park whilst completely ignoring others.

 

They both also left Motherwell having done a decent jobs there with somewhat lesser resources.

 

Could be coincidence that they had similar game plans or could it just be that they're "both shite"?

 

I can't help but feel that there must be more to it than that?

 

Are the reasons they've both been a failure been down to the same reason?

 

AFC?

 

 

[octavion]

Adequate 3

 

you guys are pulling our leg surely 

[Penfold]

F but it's as if he's being made to take the exams in Swahili due to the incompetency of the board.

[Mentorred]

I voted E. They did what they came in to do last season, save us from relegation. We have made no further progression. 

[One Bobby Clark]

I voted D, but could easily have dropped it to an E.

 

I feel the comments at the bottom of his report card would mirror mine..........

Has the capabilities but needs to learn to apply himself better and to concentrate on the task at hand.

[Harcus]

Thoughts?

 

Your poll-making is out of control.

[mizer]

Your poll-making is out of control.

 

I like polls, they make pretty graphs 

[mizer]

Browns record after 40 games in a nice graph

 

[manc_don]

Booooooo

[BobbyBiscuit]

Booooooo

 

Seconded.

 

I stepped away from this thread midweek because i had a wee sneaking suspicion we may do something today... i really should know better.

 

I said in another thread that Brown's first mistake was the line up v Celtic in the LC Semi.  the unfortunate thing is that he's done hardly anything right since.  And that's true. But sacking the manager would take the focus from Milne getting pelters, and that's what it has to come down to now.

[Jute]

Seconded.

 

I stepped away from this thread midweek because i had a wee sneaking suspicion we may do something today... i really should know better.

 

I said in another thread that Brown's first mistake was the line up v Celtic in the LC Semi.  the unfortunate thing is that he's done hardly anything right since.  And that's true. But sacking the manager would take the focus from Milne getting pelters, and that's what it has to come down to now.

 

Thing is BB we need to take action quickly to turn the league form round. Getting Milne out is not something that will happen quickly and I fear that if we leave Brown in position until that happens it could leave us looking at first division football next season. Brown needs to be got rid of now but pressure kept up on the board and Milne as well even after Browns departure.

[BobbyBiscuit]

Thing is BB we need to take action quickly to turn the league form round. Getting Milne out is not something that will happen quickly and I fear that if we leave Brown in position until that happens it could leave us looking at first division football next season. Brown needs to be got rid of now but pressure kept up on the board and Milne as well even after Browns departure.

 

Yeah, fair point but do you really think they'rre going to bin him? I don't.  I really don't.

[Dons1903]

Dark days ahead as per usual. Sometimes i wish it was 2008 when we were in europe and well above in the league. Think those days are gone now I just don't understand how the smaller teams are getting results where as we can't beat st mirren & st johnstone etc!!

[Tyrant]

I honestly don't see the point in getting rid of Broon. The problem is Milne. Whoever we get in we're just going to have to pay off 12 months down the line anyway. Going down to the 1st division might be the kick in the cunt that Milne needs? Although that's assuming we came straight back up which I just couldn't see happening.

[capitalsharpie]

I honestly don't see the point in getting rid of Broon. The problem is Milne. Whoever we get in we're just going to have to pay off 12 months down the line anyway. Going down to the 1st division might be the kick in the cunt that Milne needs? Although that's assuming we came straight back up which I just couldn't see happening.

 

The problem is with this is that failure is already accepted with milnes regime. In fact the only humiliation there is now is to be relegated. As long as the club survives one way or another the board don't seem to care.

 

Failure and mediocrity are ok. One more humiliation won't matter to Milne.

[manc_don]

I honestly don't see the point in getting rid of Broon. The problem is Milne. Whoever we get in we're just going to have to pay off 12 months down the line anyway. Going down to the 1st division might be the kick in the cunt that Milne needs? Although that's assuming we came straight back up which I just couldn't see happening.

 

Correct, brown is not the biggest problem here. I hate to say it but it seems that relegation or administration are the only two options that will force action.

 

[Tyrant]

Correct, brown is not the biggest problem here. I hate to say it but it seems that relegation or administration are the only two options that will force action.

 

I fear you are right.

[mizer]

I was asked how Brown compared to McGhee on the win loss graph - so here goes

 

 

A similar pattern is emerging

 

----

I have also had to put a DT watermark as the graphs are being plagiarised by users of other forums who then slag this forum off after stealing from it........

 

BTW did you hear about Mouse fae the Hat - bit of a nonce I hear, touching kids with his inferior boaby! 

[glasgowdon]

I was asked how Brown compared to McGhee on the win loss graph - so here goes

 

 

A similar pattern is emerging

 

----

I have also had to put a DT watermark as the graphs are being plagiarised by users of other forums who then slag this forum off after stealing from it........

 

BTW did you hear about Mouse fae the Hat - bit of a nonce I hear, touching kids with his inferior boaby! 

 

Might want to make it a bit more difficult to remove though.

[mizer]

better?