Seems like there is some good news about Shinnie's injury in that it's not as bad as the club first feared. Here's hoping they're correct!

 

Still, will be a big loss tomorrow but hopefully Hayes coming back offsets that. He's (Shinnie) has been a fantastic addition to the squad and his play has been sublime at times. How long is he going to be with us?  Fuck knows, but we should enjoy it while he is here, that's for sure.

I find it quite tragic that AFC fans covet a footballer who is clearly not good enough for an average English second division team. Certainly not as a midfielder. He is best utilised as Left Back and in the competition for places, Max Lowe is their preferred option.

 

The tragedy is twofold as it indicates the gulf in class between Scotland and England on one hand and on the other it suggests that the squad at AFC right now is less than ideal, some would say shit.

I find it quite tragic that AFC fans covet a footballer who is clearly not good enough for an average English second division team. Certainly not as a midfielder. He is best utilised as Left Back and in the competition for places, Max Lowe is their preferred option.

 

The tragedy is twofold as it indicates the gulf in class between Scotland and England on one hand and on the other it suggests that the squad at AFC right now is less than ideal, some would say shit.

 

Does it really matter who he is or is not playing for? He would make us better and is most likely available is the next window.

I find it quite tragic that AFC fans covet a footballer who is clearly not good enough for an average English second division team. Certainly not as a midfielder. He is best utilised as Left Back and in the competition for places, Max Lowe is their preferred option.

 

The tragedy is twofold as it indicates the gulf in class between Scotland and England on one hand and on the other it suggests that the squad at AFC right now is less than ideal, some would say shit.

 

Certainly a truth to what you wrote, but the fact is we miss his drive and determination on the pitch, nobody to lead by example on it, he may not be the best player in the middle of the park and I believe he is a far better left back, but he has the heart of a lion.

 

Now Derby are no great team, but it is quite sad he hasn't been given a chance, I think again his drive and determination would improve them as a team in that league, but clearly doesn't feature in the managers plans, how long their manager lasts is another matter.

 

Sadly, I don't think he will come back to us.

Does it really matter who he is or is not playing for? He would make us better and is most likely available is the next window.

 

By asking the question whether it matters where he is and whether he's playing right now or not, you miss the point.

 

He would undoubtedly improve AFC if he were to return. Therein lies the tragedy, for the two specific reasons I gave.

Unless Derby punt Cocu sharpish I'm now convinced already there is no way back for him at Derby. They aren't doing particularly well though so Cocu getting punted isn't an unrealistic proposition. When he can't even make the bench (and taking into account the shenanigans of the 3 Derby players last week, one of whom is out for the season) it says a lot what the current management think of him.

 

Derby I'm sure would prefer him to go somewhere that the receiving club can make as close a contribution to his Derby earnings as possible. That's sevco up here......but given his lack of action, any loaning club has the nap hand over Derby. Sevco have a surfeit of midfielders and I think they'd be mainly interested in him as a left back (if at all). Given that we were willing to make him the highest paid player in the club's history, we could actually end up getting him back on loan in January for a couple of grand cheaper than we were going to pay him on a new contract....albeit without having his services for 6 months. We certainly need him as things have not panned out as most of us thought they would in the heady optimistic days of pre-season

 

By asking the question whether it matters where he is and whether he's playing right now or not, you miss the point.

 

He would undoubtedly improve AFC if he were to return. Therein lies the tragedy, for the two specific reasons I gave.

 

I got your point, I’m just got past that issue a long time ago. It’s been this way for years, surprised you brought it up.

Don’t see Shinnie going to Rangers, that ship sailed, they are doing quite well and have a huge squad. They don’t need him. Don’t see him going to the Edinburgh clubs either, think if he comes north it’s back to us.

I really thought we'd be a better footballing team minus shinnie. Mainly because he is best at left back. But christ, we have a pea hearted team. Less consi and Lewis, they are spineless.

 

It's a shame things haven't worked out for him at Derby. We knew his limitations and I have to say I was surprised he even got the call from them, but to not be given a shot. Just unfair.

 

We seriously miss his drive and passion.

Started today and put in an MOM performance.

Started today and put in an MOM performance.

 

Good to hear.  We can speak about his limitations, but he is a guy who doesn't let you down and he doesn't hide and boy do we miss him.

 

Carries that form on reduces our chances of a return in January.Derby fans impressed https://dcfcfans.uk/topic/33450-graeme-shinnie/page/3/#comments

Carries that form on reduces our chances of a return in January.Derby fans impressed https://dcfcfans.uk/topic/33450-graeme-shinnie/page/3/#comments

 

I'm ok with that. As much as we need him, I want him to succeed.  It speaks better of our game if he does.

I'm ok with that. As much as we need him, I want him to succeed.  It speaks better of our game if he does.

 

This.

 

Decent strike fae the boy

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QYe9hFBaydU

Given the timing of it, as well as the sheer kwolity, that buys him hero status already. Amazing hit.

Right foot ana 

 

When he was with us it was for standing on only. And wasn't that great at even doing that