If you could pick any player from the past to play for Aberdeen who would it be

 

I would pick Martin Buchan a very talented player who did well for Man Utd as well.  When i watched him play he had the skills to make it today at the highest level

That I've seen play, Jim Bett. He could play the passes that would would make Mackie a 30 goal a season striker.

not bad for a livvy supporter  

 

zoltan varga was a genius but never got to see him

Willie Miller.

 

Cheers.

Solberg

Solberg

 

Why does everyone hate Solberg so much? From what I remember he was really good and scored lots of pens.

Why does everyone hate Solberg so much? From what I remember he was really good and scored lots of pens.

 

He turned up at the club bragging about how good he was and infact turned out to be a complete diddy!

Peter Weir, he'd be worth 15 million quid nowadays.

 

We, of course, would let his contract expire so he could leave on a free.

David Robertson, the last decent left-back we had.

Willie Miller.

Bett

My Uncle says Ernie Winchester. Don't know who he was. I suspect he's trying to be funny! 

 

I'd say Hans Gilhaus or Charlie Nicholas

My Uncle says Ernie Winchester. Don't know who he was. I suspect he's trying to be funny! 

 

I'd say Hans Gilhaus or Charlie Nicholas

 

Ernie Winchester was like the 1960s equivalent of Darren Mackie.

Joe Harper or Frank McDougall.

One of any of the following Miller,Mcleish,Strachan,Weir,Bett,Harper,Weir, Gillhaus,Archibald or Ritchie

Bobby Clark                  (or Bobby Connor  or  "Bobby" Bisconti  or  Lee "my right foot is only for standing on" Richardson" )

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

actually,  forget the Bobby Connor  vote.

"Bobby" Bisconti 

 

 

 

glad you took your comment about Connor back.  indeed.

A lot of people slagged off Bobby Connor years ago, but you have to concede that if he was playing for us today, he'd be one of our more outstanding players.

A lot of people slagged off Bobby Connor years ago, but you have to concede that if he was playing for us today, he'd be one of our more outstanding players.

 

said exactly the same thing to a mate of mine a few weeks ago and almost cried at the thought. I was one who really could not stick Roger, and I'd pray to the Gods at around 2.40 every Saturday that he wouldn't be playing. He was the weak link in a superb midfield that consisted of Jazzer, Simmie, Granty, Mason(y)  and Rico over the years . In a few hundred matches for the Dandies, he never once tackled anyone. True story.

 

Have to say though, met him a couple of times and he's a really, really good guy. Shame about the football, however.

Bobby Conner was better than anybody we've had at left midfield for a long time.

Steve Lovell 

One of any of the following Miller,Mcleish,Strachan,Weir,Bett,Harper,Weir, Gillhaus,Archibald or Ritchie

 

Steve or Byrne???

Theo Snelders

So hard as I was growing up in a time when Aberdeen were such a great team. Miller, Mcleish, Strachan etc. Also rate Gillhaus and Bett among others.

Some of the players in the 80's were not world beaters but as a team they were.

Steve or Byrne???

 

Well spotted mate. It was a reference to Steve but most on here probably don't remember him or how appalling he was. Oh and Bobby, Connor was a fine player who was much abused.

Well spotted mate. It was a reference to Steve but most on here probably don't remember him or how appalling he was. Oh and Bobby, Connor was a fine player who was much abused.

 

yeah, after watching the dross we've had over the years, I can appreciate him now. Surely a case of being rather spoiled for so many years.