Jump to content

Wednesday 1 May 2024:  kick-off 7.05pm

Scottish Youth Cup Final - Aberdeen v Rangers

Live on the BBC Scotland channel

🔴⚪️ Come on you Reds! ⚪🔴

Panda

Members
  • Posts

    1,581
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    113

Everything posted by Panda

  1. Back to a more normal looking line-up. Glad to see Duk start - as much as he's criticised he provides more than Polvara, Philips or any of the other potentials to start there.
  2. I see what you're saying, and I guess fair play for not stubbornly sticking with his decision beyond 29 minutes which is what I would have expected Robson to do. But, it was an idiotic line-up, and Robson for his faults wouldn't set up that badly. One centre back, at least four players playing out of positions leaving us really vulnerable defensively. It's cost us two points and we're fortunate to get the one we did. An elbow can't be offside, so presumably it can't play someone onside either. Hands and arms aren't counted offside, so the line isn't drawn from his elbow, it's being drawn from his hip. The angle is a bit misleading, but if it was straightened up, Miovski's head is probably offside. It's still a ridiculous decision, but more due to the laws of the game determining inches like that are offside. I don't think we have the players to play how he wants to play either. He was stressing before the game about Motherwell being more physical than us. So he knows his "muck and nettles" way of playing is going to be difficult. Nah I thought that was the correct decision. Player pushes McGrath who then knocks over Roos. But then I'm biased.
  3. It could be Mackenzie - Gartenmann - Devlin in a back three, and Shinnie and Morris as wing backs, which would be peculiar but may work on account Motherwell are shite.
  4. Oh aye, I counted three maybe four "are you with me" in yesterday's press conference which I watched from start to finish because he's such a wonderful old man.
  5. Hold on, so you're essentially a broadcast journalist? Get this boy banned. We don't need his type around here, fishing for stories and trying to find dirt on us all. Aye but he's 75 and did a documentary 20 years ago, so it's all a good laugh isn't it? Like Craig Levein. But just wonderfully loveable.
  6. Motherwell fan at work labelled this as a relegation six-pointer and hard to argue with him based on the current form and league table. For Neil Warnock, his first week was a bit of a gimme as no-one expected anything from Ibrox, and no matter how badly we played v Bonnyrigg we were probably still going to navigate that tie. Now we're at the point where he's under pressure to deliver results. A draw does nothing for us, a defeat is unthinkable. Expect Gartenmann to start, but will it be for MacDonald or Jensen with the latter injured at the weekend? Not sure any of the 'fringe' players did much on Saturday to warrant a place. Similar starting line-up to Ibrox probably. Can see Hayes being back in. Dunno what to expect. I don't think we played well at Ibrox despite the platitudes, and we definitely didn't v Bonnyrigg.
  7. That is a fucking disgrace. The Rangers allegiance is fine, it's all a bit of fun, but fuck Morton. Get him out. Get him out of our club now.
  8. Lewis/Roos' alarming drops in ability - does Craig Sampson's coaching come into question? As for the game, Rangers pressed us in possession and we couldn't handle it, wanted too much time on the ball, and we coughed up possession. Yet we could have sneaked out of there with a draw.
  9. "I applied for the Hearts job, and they gave it to some bloke from bloody Latvia or something, so that was an insult". Found that pretty cringey to be honest. Maybe cos it was actually Lithuania and I used to live with a Lithuanian, and I reckon they can manage a football team just as well as the English.
  10. Fair play for answering all the points. I still don't agree it'a a safe appointment, I think it's a risk, even short term. And I'd rather we had our new manager in earlier. I was up for giving Robson a chance because he had been coaching for years, knew the club, and had watched closely all the mistakes the previous three managers had made. So I would say that did suggest he could turn it around, and short term he did. In hindsight, he should have been assistant to another manager. You're saying Cormack is taking a deeper look at the issues - that remains to be seen. As for the training/injures comment, that wasn't me, was Kowalski I think. Listen, he's got the job now. If it works out well and Aberdeen appoint a cracking manager for next season, then I've got it wrong. Hey, I got Goodwin and, eventually, Robson wrong. Good luck to the mad bastard.
  11. Again, what is a safe hire? What is "steadying the ship"? You say Robson needed his hand held and was inexperienced, but actually his interim spell was a success. So why is Warnock as interim so crucial? Well done on missing my point. I couldn't give a fuck if he goes to bed wearing Rangers pyjamas. Someone - was either you or another poster - said that he would "stick it" to the Old Firm. What is that exactly? And what makes you think he's the man to stick it to them? It's a risky and bizarre appointment, and is a cop out from the club because the only way they need four months to find a new manager, less than a year after they were supposed to begin a new manager search, would be if they were totally clueless. Hiring Warnock is them throwing a bone to distract the dog.
  12. But so does any interim manager. And how much time do we really need to find a new boss? Do we really need four months? He has done plenty of interviews openly saying so. He calls himself "A Rangers man". He'll likely walk out to a standing ovation at Ibrox on Tuesday. Now I don't necessarily think that will affect his ability to manage Aberdeen, but let's not begin with this myth that he will stand up to the Old Firm in a way previous bosses couldn't.
  13. Here's Mark McGhee doing the same thing. We lost 3-1.
  14. Our previous managers were capable of a "rocket up the backside". Scott Brown and Graeme Shinnie have been in that dressing room. Our issues I don't think are down to a lack of work rate. Tactically is where we've failed. As for "sticking it" to Rangers and Celtic. First of all, he adores the pair of them. Secondly, what actually is sticking it to them? Is it attacking football? That's not generally Warnock, I'd be surprised if he doesn't go defensive on Tuesday. Is it getting fired in? He'll soon learn that you can't get away with that v the Old Firm in Glasgow. Will he be outspoken and call out decisions? Probably. But so are Derek Adams, Craig Levein, even Derek McInnes. What difference does it make? I actually think it's a big risk we're taking. The whole "safe pair of hands" line people have been trotting out, what does that even mean? Has he never been relegated before? Has his side never been on the end of a scudding? Think a lot of people are being bought in by the name and the celebrity. I've yet to see a good reason as to why Warnock stands out as the right choice other than wishy washy platitudes like "experienced" and regular showings of a documentary he did 20 years ago.
  15. I'm going to this one. My mate has bought two random Germans he met on holiday tickets and posted them to me so I can meet them before the game. Kinda feel I should offer my condolences as I hand the tickets over. They're Bayern Munich fans so who knows what they'll make of us. It looks increasingly like it'll be Neil Warnock in charge next week so it's just a case of whether he wants to be in the dugout that early or not. I expect that every little thing Warnock does will be amplified, good or bad. Not sure I can be arsed with the circus but here we go. As for the game - Rangers aren't that good and we're not that bad. Not impossible to get something. But I have no idea how it's going to go.
  16. If he comes in and gets some results like Robson did, and the media begin their campaign to get him the job permanently, do we bow to pressure and do just that? That doesn't strike me as sticking to this club philosophy we're supposed to have. Or is Warnock part of selecting the next manager? Because the Brexit voting Neil "I couldn't even get the job ahead of a Latvian (sic), if I can't get the job ahead of a Latvian what chance have I got" Warnock isn't the type of guy I want recommending the next boss to our board. He's an odd choice. I fear he's the wrong choice. And I really don't see why we need another long-term interim. But, I can't help but be intrigued.
  17. I am. Him & Lennon not being considered. https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/68191542
  18. I don't actually see much evidence of Neil Lennon going into struggling clubs and turning them around. Inherited good Celtic sides and a Hibs team that had just won the Scottish Cup and had a right good squad already. Sacked in Cyprus for poor results. Ultimately left Hibs in eighth. His final season at Celtic was a big failure. If anything, his track record is making good teams considerably worse. This whole "he's a winner, won't take any shit in the dressing room". So was Barry Robson, so was Jim Goodwin, and so was Scott Brown as part of Glass' team.
  19. Aye Jason Kerr followed Aberdeen on Instagram, then unfollowed them. That's how you know transfers aren't happening these days. Think it's because what they offered is essentially what we'll get in summer anyway as we'll be due a development fee. Don't take it out on the BBC. Plus I know the fella who takes pride and joy in that ins and outs article, updating it on his days off. We're all proud of him. And he's so keen he can't even be arsed getting himself up here for tomorrow's game. It honestly wouldn't surprise me if they want the next appointment to be shite so they can come out and say we should have just stuck with Robson (which, without fan pressure, they would have).
  20. Even though we haven't signed anyone (Philips apart) I think it's a good window with Miovski, Duk, Barron and Shinnie all staying. (Shinnie wasn't linked anywhere but I still worry). Kilmarnock (our biggest rivals now for fourth - that's our season now) have signed Van Veen, but he's no Miovski. Get a good manager in and we'll... it's gonna be Jack Ross isn't it?
  21. Had Robson stayed, I was convinced we would not lose, as was sure he would get a result to convince the board to stick with him. Now he's gone I'm actually less confident
  22. We're not one of the four clubs looking at Van Veen. Hearts, Motherwell, St Mirren and Kilmarnock were all after him. Looks like one of the latter two most likely to get him.
  23. Think you've been bought in by that Agent Alba joker, either directly or indirectly. Forrest is Cardiff bound I'm sure.
×
×
  • Create New...