Skip to content

Hearts v The Scottish Cup Winners

Well, here we go again, another season of joy and despair.

Hearts had a very similar League Cup group stage campaign as to what we had last season. But, as was often said about us at the beginning of last term, I'd like to see them tested before talking them up. It's easy to look impressive at home to League 2 sides.

Claudio Braga and Alexandros Kyziridis could be very good signings though, and they appear to have a dangerous front three with Shankland staying. One thing Derek McInnes generally does is get his striker scoring.

I watched the goals from their friendly with Sunderland, and if we thought Aberdeen had gifted Ipswich their three goals, it was nothing compared to Sunderland's efforts, so hard to read too much into that. But we clearly need to tighten up.

At the time of writing, with no new signings in and with Sokler, Gueye, Tobers and Gyamfi all presumably injured, I'd expect a similar team to what started v Ipswich. I wouldn't be surprised to see Morris keep his place for "experience" of going to Tynecastle, Nilsen maybe start too ahead of Aouchiche, and maybe even Dorrington in for Milne - which wouldn't be a slight on Milne, more that Dorrington and Knoester have played more games together.

But, I'm second guessing Thelin. I rarely manage to get his starting XIs correct.

Looking forward to it. I don't think in my lifetime that Aberdeen, Hearts and Hibs have all been good at the same time. The transfers they've made suggest all three could be handy this season, and it would be mouthwatering if they were (and Dundee United too), but we'll see. Likely someone will end up sacking their manager during the season - hopefully not us.

  • Replies 87
  • Views 19.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Re-the lack of friendlies, I do see the other side of it. A couple more friendlies may or may not have made the difference v Hearts. But we still would be saying we need a striker, an energetic m

  • This could have been written after any one of our final twenty games of last season. That's where the worry is. Equally, you could have written that we were easy to play against, predictable and playi

  • Whilst I can understand that being the response I would not be doing that. Constant squeeze on away support has to stop. 

Posted Images

Featured Replies

That’s the Edinburgh Tattoo has been pulled tomorrow night. Really cannot see this going ahead.

If I am honest playing this later in the season might benefit us. 

58 minutes ago, Jute said:

If I am honest playing this later in the season might benefit us

Aye, that's what we'll need come December - more fitba. 

Just now, RicoS321 said:

Aye, that's what we'll need come December - more fitba. 

Might have got a striker in by then. 

  • Author

We'd be going into our Europa League play-off having played just one game (Celtic) if this gets called off.

 

14 minutes ago, Panda said:

We'd be going into our Europa League play-off having played just one game (Celtic) if this gets called off.

 

Morton in the league cup not before the play off games? 

  • Author
30 minutes ago, Jute said:

Morton in the league cup not before the play off games? 

So it is, it's the opposite way around isn't it? 

Aye fair enough. I've written to my MSP to request a postponement.

Game currently on.

 

Just now, Jute said:

Game currently on.

 

Quite bloody right. I just made the essential journey of going for my morning coffee and there's just a bit of a breeze. Shorts, t-shirt and sandals weather. Perfect for fitba.

Just now, RicoS321 said:

Quite bloody right. I just made the essential journey of going for my morning coffee and there's just a bit of a breeze. Shorts, t-shirt and sandals weather. Perfect for fitba.

Blowing a gale here but not enough for the game to be off. 

A refreshing 49mph breeze by 8pm. COYR

  • Author

IMG_7256.thumb.jpeg.494a5037fc1479c343498b2c9f1e4597.jpeg

Think the starting XI won't be too far off this. 

My only concern about tonight is if it's the white European strip or the granite strip. 

Result wise, getting more and more confident as kick-off approaches. The talking up of Hearts - much of it by Tony Bloom - is bordering on the ridiculous. They're a decent side on their day, that's all. Think a streetwise Aberdeen will win it tonight.

30 minutes ago, Panda said:

IMG_7256.thumb.jpeg.494a5037fc1479c343498b2c9f1e4597.jpeg

Think the starting XI won't be too far off this. 

My only concern about tonight is if it's the white European strip or the granite strip. 

Result wise, getting more and more confident as kick-off approaches. The talking up of Hearts - much of it by Tony Bloom - is bordering on the ridiculous. They're a decent side on their day, that's all. Think a streetwise Aberdeen will win it tonight.

I wish I shared your confidence as I think we are still a way to go defensively (cup final when we went to a 3 aside) before we could be classed as streetwise.  I personally think Milanovic will be on from the start for extra height.  I also wouldn't be surprised to see Devlin at left back with Shinnie in midfield.  Time will tell, Thelin is hard to predict.  

Re bloom some of his quotes about ending ugly sister domination seem almost a bit mad vlad. 

47 minutes ago, tlg1903 said:

I wish I shared your confidence as I think we are still a way to go defensively (cup final when we went to a 3 aside) before we could be classed as streetwise.  I personally think Milanovic will be on from the start for extra height.  I also wouldn't be surprised to see Devlin at left back with Shinnie in midfield.  Time will tell, Thelin is hard to predict.  

Aye, with the conditions, and lack of striker, I wonder if he might go back three with Shinnie in midfield. 

I'd go something along these lines, perhaps with a lamppost ahead of Yengi instead of Keskinen, as he isn't that great up front. Meant to be a 3-5-2, but the thing didn't work

 

Screenshot_20250804-181529.png

  • Author
1 hour ago, tlg1903 said:

Re bloom some of his quotes about ending ugly sister domination seem almost a bit mad vlad. 

It shows, I think, an ignorance of Scottish football. Like "Why haven't You all been challenging the Old Firm, do you need me to come up and show you how it's done?"

He'll soon realise there are two massive clubs we're all up against. That when you begin to put a good side together that might challenge, you very quickly find other clubs with bigger budgets coming in to snap your best players up. Bloom might find his large pit of money is emptied just trying to stave off interest from English League One clubs with bigger pockets than Hearts.

Has the approach of others been poor, absolutely, and Aberdeen have underperformed for years that we only appear to slowly be trying to fix. 

But to win the league you essentially need to get lucky in one transfer window, surprise everyone, hope Celtic and Rangers have poor seasons, and get it right in one campaign before the vultures steal your best players at the end of the season. Even in England, the romantic Leicester City story, they haven't got close to a title again.

Bloom is promising the days of a two-horse race are over and that Hearts will challenge every season. They're not even challenging for third every season.

Edited by Panda

17 minutes ago, Panda said:

It shows, I think, an ignorance of Scottish football. Like "Why haven't You all been challenging the Old Firm, do you need me to come up and show you how it's done?"

He'll soon realise there are two massive clubs we're all up against. That when you begin to put a good side together that might challenge, you very quickly find other clubs with bigger budgets coming in to snap your best players up. Bloom might find his large pit of money is emptied just trying to stave off interest from English League One clubs with bigger pockets than Hearts.

Has the approach of others been poor, absolutely, and Aberdeen have underperformed for years that we only appear to slowly be trying to fix. 

But to win the league you essentially need to get lucky in one transfer window, surprise everyone, hope Celtic and Rangers have poor seasons, and get it right in one campaign before the vultures steal your best players at the end of the season. Even in England, the romantic Leicester City story, they haven't got close to a title again.

Bloom is promising the days of a two-horse race are over and that Hearts will challenge every season. They're not even challenging for third every season.

Hard to argue with any of that.  That said for someone else to win the league I think the only way it happens is by finishing second one season, somehow navigating the CL qualifiers assuming second place gets you into it, and getting to the league phase. Only then is a club going to have the finance to take a proper swing for 1st place in the league imo.

21 minutes ago, tlg1903 said:

527799529_1331164485685356_4602044997803657574_n.jpg

Forgot about Nilsen. Makes sense alongside Clarkson. Hope the Aouchiche lad does a power of work to help out (not questioning his work rate like, seemed reasonable, just got caught on the ball a bit). Think I'd have gone back three. Surprised to see Milne keep his place, but pleasantly so. 

Edit: just spotted Sokler on the bench, and nae Ambrose. 

Edited by RicoS321

It’s a good line up and not surprising to see palaversa on the bench and nilsen back. We will need his strength and leadership. 
 

All this moaning about 50mph winds, you lot need to try living in Wellington, that’s fuck all here, more of a gentle breeze. Doesn’t even register if it’s below 100km and trains and sports continue like normal. Think somewhere win the South Island recently had gusts of 250 kmh 🫣 which is bonkers. Anyway, I digress, get fucking stuck in and wipe the smiles from attendance FC please.

Shambles, shinnie dives into midfield. Kisses it and they get in behind. He then gets to put it into the net too.

 

He's past it at left back. Also can't believe we've played clarkson in the middle at tynecastle. We've learned nothing.

Sounds like it’s going well 🙈 what do we need to change?

Not sharp enough, not aggressive enough.

I mean milanovic has been good 😂

6 minutes ago, Slim said:

Not sharp enough, not aggressive enough.

Not watching, do they look match fit given they’ve played a few (competitive) games??

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.