Skip to content

Comparing the ECWC team with today's footballers

Not sure if this will have legs, but...

 

I was chatting to a younger Dons fan the other night and telling them about some of the players who won us the ECWC.  I was explaining that McLeish was a very classy centre half and I was asked for comparisons with any players playing today.  I suggested there was perhaps similarities to the likes of (Rio) Fedinand or Pique.

 

Which got me thinking, who in world football today could we compare to some of the team who won us the ECWC?

 

Jim Leighton

Doug Rougvie

Alex McLeish

Willie Miller

John McMaster

Neale Cooper

Gordon Strachan

Neil Simpson

Mark McGhee

Eric Black

Peter Weir

 

John Hewitt

Stuart Kennedy

Bryan Gunn

Andy Watson

Ian Angus

Featured Replies

WM was/is incomparable in modern football.

 

Puyol is more of a McLeish

 

Nesta?

 

Hierro?

From what I have seen of weir there was a certain cruyffness about the way he beat men and distributed the ball.  Nests isn't a bad shout for miller to be fair, he def had a bit of an Italian style wig regards to knowing when to make a tactical foul

With regards rather, fucking touch screen phones

Rougvie was hardly unique though. He was probably THE stereotypical 80s full back. An athlete with tree trunk legs who'd bomb about all day. Stuart Pearce, Viv Anderson, Mel Sterland, Gary Stevens types.

 

I'd say there has been a move away from that type of fullback though the boy Ivanovic fae Chelsea is a possible.

 

Black = Berbatov?

 

I would have thought Jerome Boateng was a bit of a throw back to an '80s full back at least in stature and physicality.

Miller - Baresi, as for a modern day player, Cannavaro?

  • Author

Miller - Baresi, as for a modern day player, Cannavaro?

 

Both good shouts.

 

I'm surprised none of the younger fans have accused us all of being mad what with some of the names being compared, but the ECWC team were that good!  :thumbsup:

I'm surprised none of the younger fans have accused us all of being mad what with some of the names being compared, but the ECWC team were that good!  :thumbsup:

 

You = mad.

Miller - Baresi

 

Interesting one. Gabriele Marcotti has stated on more than one occasion that Willie Miller was a better player than Baresi.  I can see the comparison though.

We need to push to get Miller in the FIFA 12 classic XI team

Both good shouts.

 

I'm surprised none of the younger fans have accused us all of being mad what with some of the names being compared, but the ECWC team were that good!  :thumbsup:

 

I thought yesterday that maybe we were overstating their worth and also it should be remembered that they were  team, more than the sum of their parts.

 

But in my eyes those parts, the Gothenburg Legends, are heroes and the these cunts from today couldn't hold a torch to them. :)

  • Author

How about Carrick for Neale Cooper??

How about Carrick for Neale Cooper??

 

Makelele?

How about Carrick for Neale Cooper??

 

Carrick can't tackle. Cooper couldn't pass it as well as Carrick.

I fucking wish I was alive in those days. It's depressing only bring a fan from 1999s to present. The worst time to be a dons fan surley?

I thought yesterday that maybe we were overstating their worth and also it should be remembered that they were  team, more than the sum of their parts.

 

But in my eyes those parts, the Gothenburg Legends, are heroes and the these cunts from today couldn't hold a torch to them. :)

 

What he said

I fucking wish I was alive in those days. It's depressing only being a fan from 1990s to present. The worst time to be a dons fan surley?

 

Pretty much. It's great, join the party :thumbsup:

I fucking wish I was alive in those days. It's depressing only bring a fan from 1999s to present. The worst time to be a dons fan surley?

 

Me to, born year off glory, been downhill since  :

 

Can only get bettter

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.